Part One: The Red Line
I’ve been riding the Red Line in Chicago for twenty-six years, and I like to think I’ve seen everything a train car can hold. I’ve seen a man play a full set on a tuba between Belmont and Fullerton. I’ve seen a woman knit an entire baby sweater on her commute over the course of one winter, and when she finished it, half the car applauded. I’ve seen a wedding proposal, three fistfights, a lost parakeet, and once, at two in the morning, a priest and a drag queen splitting a bag of Garrett popcorn and arguing about the Cubs. What I’d never seen before that Saturday in October was the kind of quiet, deliberate meanness that wears a nice coat and tells itself it’s just taking up its fair share.
My name is Teresa Kowalski. I’m fifty-two years old, and I’m a charge nurse in the emergency department at a hospital on the South Side. I work Saturday days, seven to seven, and I take the Red Line from my apartment in Edgewater all the way down to work, forty minutes each way if nothing goes wrong. Twenty-six years of emergency nursing teaches you a few things. It teaches you to read a room fast. It teaches you that the people who are loudest about their pain are usually not the ones in the most trouble. And it teaches you to tell the difference between a person who’s taking up space because they don’t know any better and a person who’s taking it because they know exactly what it costs someone else.
That Saturday morning I’d gotten a seat near the middle doors of the sixth car, which is my car, the same one I ride every week, because it stops right at the stairs at Sox–35th. I had my coffee in a travel mug and a paperback mystery I’d been trying to finish for a month. The train was about two-thirds full: weekend riders, a few tourists with maps, some kids in Bears jerseys headed somewhere early, a man asleep against the window with his mouth open. It was a perfectly ordinary October morning, gray and cold off the lake.
I was sitting across from him when I first noticed.
He was a big man, broad through the shoulders, maybe forty, and well-dressed in a way that told you he wanted you to notice. Charcoal wool overcoat, open over a navy quarter-zip. Good jeans. Brown leather boots that had never seen salt or slush. He had a fresh haircut and a watch that caught the light every time he lifted his phone. He was scrolling something with his thumb and wearing the faint, satisfied expression of a man who has never once in his life wondered whether he was in anyone’s way.
And his knees were spread so wide that the women on both sides of him were squeezed into half of their own seats.
I don’t mean a little. I mean he was sitting in the center of three molded plastic seats and occupying the better part of all three. His left knee pressed hard against the leg of a young woman holding a toddler on her lap, and his right knee jutted across into the seat of a middle-aged woman with a grocery tote, who had folded herself sideways against the pole like a closed umbrella. Both of them were trying, in the way women have learned to try, to make themselves smaller without making a fuss. The young mother had her son pulled tight against her chest and her own knees pressed together and angled toward the aisle, and still that big knee followed her, sitting heavily against her thigh as the train rocked.
I watched for two stops. I told myself it might be an accident. Some big men honestly don’t notice. My own late husband, God rest him, used to sprawl across our couch like a dropped coat and was always genuinely surprised to learn he was crushing somebody. So I waited to see whether the man would catch himself.
He didn’t. Every time the young mother shifted a fraction of an inch away from him, his knee drifted that same fraction to follow.
Part Two: “Then Stand”
The younger woman finally spoke. She couldn’t have been more than twenty-five, with her hair pulled back in a quick ponytail and a diaper bag hanging off one shoulder. Her son was maybe two, sleepy and heavy against her, sucking his thumb with his eyes half closed. She cleared her throat and said it politely, the way you’d ask a stranger to pass the salt.
“Excuse me. Could you move your leg?”
He barely looked up from his phone. “I’m a big guy.”
“Your knee is in my seat,” she said. Her voice was steady, but I saw her arm tighten around her son.
“Then move over.”
“There’s nowhere to go.” She nodded at the end of the bench, where the metal partition pressed against her other shoulder. She was already sitting on the last two inches of plastic.
He finally looked at her then, and he smirked. It was a small smile, almost lazy, the kind that tells you a person has had this exact conversation many times before and has always won it.
“Then stand,” he said.
He went back to his phone. The young woman looked at him for a moment, and I watched her decide that it wasn’t worth it, not with a two-year-old on her lap and a long day ahead of her. She looked out the window instead. Two stops later, at Roosevelt, she gathered up her son and her diaper bag and got off the train. I don’t know if that was really her stop. I suspect it wasn’t.
A tiny elderly woman with a cane took her place.
She had boarded at Roosevelt, moving slowly and carefully through the doors, and she must have been in her eighties: five feet tall at most, in a long camel-colored wool coat that had been beautiful once and was still very well kept, with a plum-colored beret pinned to her white hair and a church bulletin sticking out of her handbag. She leaned on a dark wooden cane with a brass tip, and she lowered herself into the open seat with the particular care of someone who has learned not to trust her hips.
Within seconds, his knee was pressing against her coat.
She noticed. I watched her notice. She shifted toward the partition, gathered her coat around her legs, tucked her cane against her shoulder. The knee followed. She looked down at it, and then she looked up at him with an expression I recognized from a thousand patients: polite, patient, and just a little bit disappointed in the world.
“Sir,” she said, “could you give me some room?”
He sighed, a long and theatrical exhalation, like she had asked him to carry her groceries up four flights. “I’m six-four,” he said. “Where do you expect my legs to go?”
She considered the question seriously, as if it deserved an answer. “Just,” she said, “in front of you?”
Part Three: Nobody Asked You
I couldn’t stay quiet anymore. Twenty-six years in the ER, and I have stood between a lot of people and a lot of bad decisions. My mouth was open before my better judgment had a chance to weigh in.
“She shouldn’t have to sit sideways,” I said, “because you want two seats.”
His head snapped toward me. For the first time he really looked at me: a short, round, gray-haired woman in navy scrubs and a puffy purple coat, holding a travel mug with a sticker on it that said World’s Okayest Nurse. I watched him dismiss me in about half a second. I’ve been dismissed by surgeons with better haircuts than his.
“Nobody asked you,” he said.
“She’s asking you,” I said.
A few people in the car had started paying attention. The kids in the Bears jerseys had stopped talking. A man in a Northwestern sweatshirt lowered his earbuds. The woman with the grocery tote on the man’s other side, still folded against her pole, glanced at me with an expression that was half gratitude and half please don’t make it worse.
He leaned back against the window and spread his arms along the top of the seat back, like he was settling into his own living room. “If she’s uncomfortable,” he said, loud enough for the whole car, “she can stand. Give her your seat if you care so much.”
And then the elderly woman started pushing herself up. She did it slowly, with her cane planted on the floor and her free hand on the pole, a tiny woman in her eighties getting to her feet on a moving train so that a forty-year-old man could have more room for his knees. I’ve seen a lot of things make me angry in my life, but I’m not sure I’ve ever been as angry as I was in that moment.
“No,” I said, and I said it in my charge-nurse voice, the one I use when a drunk in Bed Four is trying to pull out his IV. “Stay.”
She looked at me, surprised. Then, slowly, she sat back down.
The man laughed. He actually laughed, a short bark of a sound. Then he leaned back even further and spread his knees even wider, until the old woman’s coat was crumpled against the partition and the woman with the grocery tote was practically hugging her pole.
“What are you gonna do?” he said, grinning at me across the aisle. “Make me close my legs?”
Before I could answer, the train pulled into Cermak–Chinatown and the doors slid open. A huge man in a work jacket stepped on. I mean huge, six-six at least, built like a refrigerator, in a canvas Carhartt jacket stiff with drywall dust and a hard hat clipped to his belt. He looked like he’d come off an overnight shift and wanted nothing in this world but to sit down. The car was full except for one spot: the narrow sliver of seat between Mr. Big Guy’s right knee and the woman with the grocery tote.
The woman with the tote, God bless her, saw her chance. She stood up, smiled at the construction worker, and said, “Here, honey, take mine,” and moved to stand by the doors. The construction worker nodded his thanks, turned around, and sat.
Instantly, the knees snapped together.
I mean instantly. It was like watching a pair of garden shears close. One moment, Mr. Big Guy was sprawled across three seats with his arms along the backs like a king on a throne. The next, the construction worker’s thigh was pressed against his, and his knees had pulled in so fast I heard the fabric of his good jeans whisper. He put his arms down. He pulled his elbows in. He sat up straight. For two stops, all the way to Sox–35th, he somehow fit perfectly inside his own seat, as neat and compact as a schoolboy in the principal’s office.
He did not look at the construction worker once. He did not say a word about being six-four.
Part Four: The Smile
At Sox–35th the construction worker got off, and I should have gotten off too. That was my stop; I had a shift starting in twenty minutes. But I sat there with my coffee and my paperback in my lap, because something had just become very clear to me, and I wanted to see if I was right.
A woman took the construction worker’s place: a slender woman in her thirties in a gray coat with a laptop bag, who sat down carefully with her knees together and her bag on her lap. For about thirty seconds, nothing happened. Then, slowly, as the train swayed out of the station, that knee began to drift outward again. An inch. Two inches. Until it was resting heavily against her thigh.
She glanced down at it and shifted toward the aisle. He noticed her discomfort. I watched him notice it. And he smiled.
That was when I understood. It wasn’t an accident, and it wasn’t that he didn’t know how big he was. He knew exactly how big he was, and he knew exactly what he was doing. He’d folded himself up as small as a pocketknife the moment a man bigger than him sat down, and he’d unfolded again the moment that man was replaced by a woman. He wasn’t taking up space because he needed it. He was taking up space because he could, because he’d figured out a long time ago that most women would rather stand than fight, and he enjoyed watching them choose.
I’ve treated men like that in the emergency room. Not physically like him, but in the way they move through a room. They’re very polite to the doctors and very rude to the nurses. They call the male residents “Doc” and call me “sweetheart.” They know exactly whose discomfort they can afford.
I looked at the old woman with the cane, still squeezed against the partition, her plum beret slightly askew. I looked at the woman in the gray coat, now perched on the edge of her seat with her laptop bag clutched to her chest. Then I looked out the window at the gray October morning sliding past, and I took out my phone and did some quick arithmetic in my head.
It was 7:22 on a Saturday. The next stop was 47th, then Garfield, then 63rd. And on the third Saturday of every October for the last six years, I knew exactly who would be standing on the platform at 47th Street at 7:26 in the morning, because I’d ridden with them a dozen times and cheered for them twice that many. I sent a quick text, and I got an answer back in under ten seconds, because my daughter has never once in her life been more than three inches from her phone.
Part Five: Would You Trust Me?
At Garfield, I stood up.
He watched me rise from my seat, and his smirk came back. “Finally leaving?” he asked.
“No,” I said.
I crossed the aisle, holding the pole as the train lurched, and I leaned down toward the women on either side of him: the elderly woman with the cane on his left and the woman in the gray coat on his right. I spoke quietly, but not so quietly that I was hiding anything. I wanted him to hear that something was coming. I just didn’t want him to hear what.
“Would you trust me,” I asked them, “for two minutes?”
The two women exchanged a look across him, the old woman’s pale blue eyes meeting the younger woman’s brown ones over the broad expanse of his navy quarter-zip. I saw something pass between them, the silent conversation women have been having across men for about ten thousand years. Then they both nodded.
I leaned closer and whispered one thing to them. Just one sentence. The old woman’s eyebrows went up under her plum beret. The woman in the gray coat put a hand over her mouth, and I saw her shoulders shake once.
The man laughed. “Oh, this should be good,” he said. “What are you doing, lady? Organizing a protest?”
“You’ll see,” I said, and I went back to my seat across the aisle and sat down with my coffee.
He kept smirking. He tipped his head back against the window and closed his eyes, the very picture of a man who had never lost an argument on public transit and did not intend to start now. His knees stayed exactly where they were, spread wide across three seats’ worth of plastic.
The train slowed for 47th Street. Through the window I could see the platform sliding into view, and on it, right where the sixth car would stop, a crowd of young women in matching navy-and-gold warm-up jackets, with duffel bags over their shoulders and their hair pulled back in tight braids. A few of them were holding cleats tied together by the laces. One of them was carrying a ball shaped like an oversized egg.
When the doors began to open, I winked at the two women.
“Ready?” I asked.
They nodded.
Part Six: The Lakeshore Ladies
For a second, he still looked smug. He had his eyes closed and his head back, and he didn’t see the doors open or the crowd of young women stepping on, laughing and talking, the car suddenly full of the sound of twenty voices and the squeak of sneakers on the rubber floor.
Then the old woman with the cane stood up, quick and neat, and the woman in the gray coat stood up at the same moment on his other side. “Here, girls,” the old woman said brightly, in a voice that carried. “We’re getting off soon. Take ours.”
And the two largest members of the Lakeshore Ladies Women’s Rugby Football Club sat down on either side of him.
I should explain about the Lakeshore Ladies. They’re an amateur women’s rugby club in Chicago, one of the best in the Midwest, and on the third Saturday of every October they play their biggest match of the fall season against a club from Milwaukee at a park on the South Side. They board the Red Line together at 47th Street because their captain lives on that block and makes everybody meet at her apartment for oatmeal at six-thirty. I know this because their captain, for the past three seasons, has been my daughter.
Madeleine Kowalski is twenty-six years old. She’s five-eleven and weighs one hundred and ninety pounds, and she plays tighthead prop, which, for those who don’t follow rugby, is the position in the front of the scrum where you lock shoulders with the biggest player on the other team and push. She has a degree in civil engineering, and she can deadlift more than any man in her office. She is also, I’ll have you know, the gentlest person I’ve ever met. She cries at dog food commercials. She knits.
The text I’d sent from my seat was short. Car 6, middle doors. Need my two biggest girls to sit in two seats. Long story. Trust me.
Her answer had come back nine seconds later. Me and Big Shan. Coming in hot.
Big Shan is Shannon Okafor, the team’s loosehead prop, Maddie’s partner in the front row. She’s twenty-eight, six-one, and she’s played rugby since she was fourteen. She’s a kindergarten teacher in Bronzeville. She has a laugh you can hear from across a field, and shoulders like a doorway.
So that’s who sat down on either side of him. My daughter on his left, in the old woman’s seat. Big Shan on his right, in the gray coat woman’s seat. Both of them in their warm-up jackets with their duffel bags on their laps, both of them smiling the warm, open, friendly smiles of women who had just been given a seat on a crowded train.
And his knees snapped together.
It was even faster than with the construction worker. His eyes flew open and his whole body jerked upright as two very large, very solid women settled into the plastic seats beside him, each one sitting exactly the way she always sits, which is to say comfortably, naturally, like an athlete, with her knees at a normal angle and her shoulders square. Neither of them sprawled. Neither of them pressed. They simply occupied their own seats fully, the way he never had, and there turned out to be no room left over for his.